Showing Judgement or Making Judgements
July 13, 2023

This week sees a number of disparate strands coming together with a core important message for all of us in our daily lives. Strand one is that we have all witnessed a media frenzy about the alleged actions of the BBC presenter we now know is Huw Edwards.

Strand two is the story we shall read in our service on Saturday morning – a morality tale in which Tamar teaches her father-in-law Judah a vital life lesson in a very unorthodox way!

Strand three is the welcoming of new lives into our synagogue community, as Adam and Clare bring their children Jacob and Lyra Crego for a naming and blessing ceremony. Please come and join them and us for this happy celebration.

Let me explain what binds these three strands together. Yesterday, it became clear that, whatever is the truth about the allegations published, there is a story here that should invoke our sympathy for someone, news anchor and presenter, Huw Edwards, who has been struggling with depression and its impact for a long time.

It might become clear, when all is known to those who should be privy to the details, that he has acted badly. At that time, our Judaism teaches that only those involved can pass judgement on the actions, but not condemn or vilify the person. The wider public, including us, needs to leave this process of reaching a sound and wise judgement to those people who should make it. To do otherwise is to create mob rule, kangaroo courts and the like. It is also to commit sins of lashon hara – spreading gossip, slander and libel.

One reason for this distinction between the act and the actor is that all of us, as our High Holy Day liturgy will remind us, are sinners. All of us have spoken or acted in ways that we shouldn’t. Therefore, Rabbi Akiva’s guiding principle of “Do not do to others anything which you would hate to be done to you” would cause us to refrain from making judgements about other people.

In strand two, Tamar, Judah’s daughter-in-law, is wronged by her father-in-law by being left widowed and without the husband that the laws of the land would have given her. She sets a trap for Judah, which leads to him fathering her child. He explodes when hearing that she is pregnant and determines to punish capitally! She proves that he is the father of her child and he has to eat humble pie and acknowledge that he was in the wrong.

Here again, one lesson from this story is that we must not be quick to judge others. Rather we must withhold judgement until we understand what has happened and why, and consider what our role might have been.

How does all this link to strand three – the happy celebration of new life at Saturday’s service? I suggest that one of the deepest roles of parents is to raise their children that they learn to possess good judgement rather than to become harsh and judgemental in their attitude towards others. When we ask God’s blessing upon Jacob and Lyra Crego, we do so knowing that their parents are also in need of divine guidance – as are we all. If each of us can keep learning how to show judgement rather than make judgements, then the world in which Jacob and Lyra grow up will be a calmer and better one. Surely, that’s what we all want!

 

Rabbi Richard Jacobi

0 Comments