Being In Step Or Not
October 23, 2025

Some of you will have noticed that we read the traditional Torah portion last week and are now wholly back in step with the rest of the Jewish world. For fifteen years, we followed a novel approach to reading the Torah, developed by Rabbi Pete Tobias. For many Shabbat morning regulars, it meant that we explored the Torah in greater depth, but it also meant that when other organisations, such as Leo Baeck College and the World Union for Progressive Judaism, wrote about the weekly Torah portion, we weren’t reading anything from that portion.

So, earlier in the year, your Rites and Practices committee and I agreed that we would revert to the traditional cycle of Torah readings, AND that we would try to find interesting and challenging passages within each portion to stretch and challenge ourselves.

So, this Shabbat, Nick Young will be reading from the final chapter of parshat Lech Lecha and the covenant between God and Avram, including the change of his name to the more familiar Avraham (Abraham in English). I hope you will join him for the service.

The question of when to be ‘in step’ with others and when not to fall in line is one addressed by the Midrash, which said, “Abraham was called a Hebrew because while the whole world stood on one side, he stood on the other.” (Genesis Rabbah 42:8)

It can be very tempting to join the crowd, to fall in line with a majority, but the very meaning of being a Hebrew is to be willing to stand away from, or even in opposition to the masses, when they are going in the wrong direction. Exodus 23:2 states “Do not follow the majority to do evil.” We have a responsibility to exercise moral judgement, to make our own decision, based upon our best understanding of Jewish values, and, if necessary, to go against the masses.

As an example, when too many in the Jewish community now support Tommy Robinson – a rabble-rousing, violent (he was imprisoned for assault), hate-speaker – we have to hold fast to our moral values. He might voice support for Israel, but that is for some right-wing nationalist politicians, whose values he shares, and whose aspirations are anathema to our liberal form of Judaism. Yes, it can feel like a lonely challenge, but this is where our ELELS community should always be a source of support.

There are times when it is right and good to be in step with the rest of the Jewish world and / or our neighbours in our local area – Redbridge, Waltham Forest, Epping, or elsewhere. However, we need to ensure that we join them only when it is right and good. As a liberal, inclusive, values-based Jewish community, we will always follow Abraham’s example and, where we judge it to be appropriate, stand up for those values even if that means going against the crowd.

I wish you all a Shabbat shalom,

Rabbi Richard Jacobi

 

 

0 Comments