Pesach and Freedom for ALL
March 31, 2026

Retelling the story of Pesach each year is one of the most widely celebrated rituals across the Jewish world. Most of our synagogue community will mark it, on the first and / or second night or in some other way.

In our Haggadah, the meal divides the longer first section of the Seder, which takes us back to the redemption from slavery in Egypt, from the shorter and more light-hearted looking to the future and ultimate redemption for all. By way of contrast, if you find yourself reading an orthodox Haggadah, you will find references to the rebuilding of the Temple, to other enemies of the Israelites meeting their demise, and so on.

Indeed, our closing lines are “let us pray for the Passover of the future, when all humanity will live in harmony and peace. Next year in Jerusalem, next year in a world where all are free!” This compares to the orthodox ending (which actually precedes the songs), which is particularistic, focussing on freedom for all Jews, so that all will gather in a rebuilt Jerusalem.

An important part of our Progressive worldview is that we believe true freedom can only come when all are free. The more regressive (or orthodox nationalist) belief of the current Israeli government seems to believe that a dominant Jewish state, which oppresses others, is the route to a viable long-term future.

In keeping with their views, the coalition government passed a law in the Knesset that extends capital punishment only to non-Jewish terrorists. Progressive movements in Israel and around the world have condemned the passing of this law. Our own movement’s statement is below, as is the Israel movement statement.

A former speaker of the Knesset has defined the current war as fundamentalist Christianity and fundamentalist Judaism fighting against fundamentalist Islam. This is a credible analysis, and one which ought to concern us all.

There are many allies in this country and in Israel who seek to advance the values we uphold in the social, economic and political spheres. Building partnerships and alliances will help us defeat extremism of any sort. Indeed, the exodus story of the Haggadah told that an “erev rav – a mixed multitude” left Egypt with the Israelites (Ex. 12:38). The best path to success is in collaboration with others.

In our Progressive synagogue, we need to keep the flame of liberalism alight, however unlikely that future might seem. Only if we keep working for a better world for all God’s creatures will we possibly achieve this messianic future for which we pray as we conclude our Seder.

Let us be strong and strengthen one another this Pesach!

Rabbi Richard Jacobi

Statement by the Movement for Progressive Judaism (UK) – 31st March 2026

The Movement for Progressive Judaism condemns the Knesset’s passage of this death penalty law.

This is not a serious security measure. It is a dangerous act of political extremism.

A state does not become stronger by giving itself greater power to kill. It becomes weaker when it abandons restraint, equality before the law and the moral seriousness that justice demands.

This law is especially alarming because it is structured in a way that appears designed to apply overwhelmingly to Palestinians tried in military courts. That is not justice. It is discrimination written into law.

Jewish tradition is not casual about the power of the state to take life. The rabbis placed such extraordinary barriers around capital punishment precisely because they understood that a system of vengeance will always risk becoming a system of abuse. A society under trauma must be even more careful with power, not less.

And this law is reckless as well as wrong. Israeli security experts have repeatedly warned that measures like this do not deter violence. They risk inflaming it, increasing danger to hostages, deepening hatred, and further corroding Israel’s democratic foundations.

At a moment when Israelis and Palestinians alike are already living with unbearable fear, grief and instability, the answer cannot be revenge dressed up as policy.

We stand with those in Israel fighting for a different future: one rooted not in cruelty and domination, but in justice, equality, human dignity and the sanctity of life.

 

** Public Statement by The Israel Movement for Reform and Progressive Judaism and the Council of Reform Rabbis in Israel **

The Death Penalty for Terrorists Law passed by the Knesset this week is a moral disgrace.

It is a law that has no place in a democratic state, and indeed an overwhelming majority of Western nations have abolished the death penalty, as Israel itself did in 1954. At that time, religious authorities, led by the Chief Rabbinate, supported its abolition. As Rabbi Ben-Zion Meir Hai Uziel, the first Sephardi Chief Rabbi of the State of Israel, stated:

“The outlook of Jewish law, which has shaped the spirit of the people of Israel as a whole, is to prevent capital punishment as much as possible… The State of Israel denies the courts the authority to decide upon and carry out death sentences in any form whatsoever.”

The death penalty contradicts the values of Judaism, a religion that sanctifies life. As we teach: “Whoever destroys a single soul, it is as if they have destroyed an entire world; and whoever sustains a single soul, it is as if they have sustained an entire world” (Babylonian Talmud, Sanhedrin 37a). Specifically, regarding executions, Rabbi Tarfon and Rabbi Akiva ruled: “A Sanhedrin that executes once in seventy years is called destructive… Had we been in the Sanhedrin, no one would ever have been put to death” (Tractate Makkot 1:10). Maimonides also opposed the death penalty, stating: “It is better to acquit a thousand guilty persons than to execute a single innocent one” (Mishneh Torah, Laws of Sanhedrin 12:3).

The law passed by the Knesset is particularly severe because it differentiates between Jewish blood and Palestinian blood, applying the death penalty only to Palestinian terrorists and not to perpetrators of Jewish terror. Preferring Jewish lives over Palestinian lives contradicts the principle that all are created in the image of God and violates the prohibition against discrimination. The Babylonian Talmud teaches: “What makes you think your blood is redder? Perhaps that man’s blood is redder.” Discriminating between one life and another is an abomination that stands in opposition to Jewish values.

Members of Knesset who wear a noose pin on their lapel are a disgrace to Jewish tradition, a stain on the identity of the state as both Jewish and democratic, and a desecration of God’s name as they seek to harm the divine image within us. It is incomprehensible to witness their cries of joy over the passage of this law.

Jewish teaching opposes acting out of vengeance: “You shall not take revenge nor bear a grudge” (Leviticus 19:18). Even in times of war, we must not act out of vengeance and anger. Even while waging a military campaign against a cruel enemy, we must adhere to Jewish values of justice, love of humanity, and compassion. We must choose life, not celebrate death.

The Death Penalty for Terrorists Law must be erased from the statute books. It is immoral, inhuman, and antithetical to Jewish tradition

 

 

0 Comments