New Year – Renewed Determination
January 8, 2026

2026 has started in dramatic and unexpected – at least by me – ways. Let me try to connect our Torah portion, Venezuela and the threat to Greenland, and the testimonies of Gaza hostages for you.

The most important sessions I attended at last week’s Limmud Festival gave me the privilege of witnessing the testimony of hostages who had been held in Gaza and of relatives of Israelis who had been murdered.

Aviva and Keith Siegel were held by Hamas for 51 and 484 days respectively, having been captured from their home in Kibbutz Kfar Aza on 7th October 2023. Both had experienced the sort of trauma that you or I would find unimaginable, and both spoke with moral clarity that I could only admire, respect, and appreciate. They were very ordinary people, just like the families of our community, who were thrust into a situation of extreme horror, and who have emerged to be in the public arena with vital messages for us to hear.

Both sat in tunnels in Gaza believing one of their four children had been killed on October 7th. Only when they emerged did they find out he was still alive and well. Both experienced and witnessed cruelty and torture, as well as the most challenging physical, mental and emotional conditions. Aviva Siegel sees the current time, with only one deceased hostage still in Gaza, as particularly dangerous, because where do we focus. She encouraged us all to spend time around the dinner table talking about nice and kind things. Don’t spend that time talking about hatred and fear. This week, her advice feels even more relevant than it did just a few days ago.

The testimony of Keith and Aviva Siegel is about much more than what they experienced. It is about how they and we have to hold on to our values whatever life throws at us. This was further affirmed by Sharone Lifschitz from Kibbutz Nir Ozand now based in London, whose parents – Yocheved and Oded, founders of the kibbutz – were abducted on October 7th. Her mother was released after 17 days, but her father was killed in captivity and his body returned last February. Sharone consistently argues that we need compassion towards each other. The narrative, she says, has to change – “it’s not me or you, but me and you”.

Magen Inon, whose parents were murdered on 7th October, is an educator, whose response to family tragedy has been to educate and campaign for long-term peace between Israelis and Palestinians. He told us that the only stability for Israel has come through peace agreements with Egypt and Jordan. Our goal for the next 5 to 50 years has to be to bring about that peace between Israelis and Palestinians.

All four of these people also support the pro-democracy campaigns in Israel. They do so because they know that the current authoritarian government created the conditions over the past few years for October 7th to happen. They also fear what might be done to dismantle Israel’s democracy, threatening so many of their and our core values.

We are witnessing in America the greatest challenge to the rules-based order established after 1945. The attack on Venezuela might well embolden President Trump towards Greenland, which will cause a major crisis for NATO and for our country. His authoritarian government and “might is right” approach is exceedingly dangerous for us as Jews, and for the wider world. Remember, among this President’s first acts was to pardon about 1,500 people who criminally rioted on 6th January 2021, including men who wore Camp Auschwitz hoodies or T-shirts emblazoned with 6MWE. This is short for “Six Million Wasn’t Enough”!

The eighth verse of Exodus chapter 1 states: “There arose a new king over Egypt who did not know Joseph…” He viewed the future as “me or you” to use Sharone Lifschitz’s phrase, and so he enslaved the Israelites, seeing them as some kind of ‘fifth column’ enemy within the Egyptian population.

President Trump also adopts ‘me or you” language in the most extreme way. His and Natnayahu’s type of authoritarian government never ends well for us Jews, and it is never good for the wider population, especially other minorities, either. No matter how tempting some expensive advertising and catchy slogans might seem, we need to hold to our principles.

When a mainstream Jewish columnist such a Jonathan Freedland writes, as he did last month, in Jewish News that we should have nothing to do with someone who is not repentant about past antisemitic statements, I think we should all take note.

Our form of Judaism, now united under the banner of Progressive Judaism, is safest and healthiest in liberal democracies, with all their imperfections and frustrations. We need to keep anyone with authoritarian tendencies well away from power, and so I hope we will all act in our own and our community’s best interests in 2026.

Rabbi Richard Jacobi

0 Comments