Why are so many people profoundly affected by what happened on and since 7th October 2023?
This is a question that I have been pondering since a couple of days after the initial, horrendous news emerged of the terror attacks launched by Hamas on that date. My ponderings have only become more complex as events have unfolded since.
A powerful session I attended with my rabbinic and cantorial colleagues on Tuesday proved very helpful to all present in explaining this phenomenon. Dr. Talya Greene, now an Associate Professor at University College London presented to us about “Moral Injury” and how this is relevant in different ways to people responding to the Israel – Gaza war.
Moral injury occurs when we experience something that profoundly conflicts with our core personal values AND it scars us, such that we cannot easily recover our previous moral framework.
More specifically, for many Israelis, especially those who championed peaceful co-existence and the two-state solution, the events of October 7th shattered those beliefs. Peaceniks were among those murdered, brutalised, and taken hostage. Many of these Israelis cannot re-gain any sort of equilibrium until the last hostages have been returned.
Others living in Israel, Gaza, and elsewhere around the world have felt their moral compass thrown off-kilter by the nature of Israel’s response and the number of civilians, and especially children, who have been killed.
As we all know, this has produced a polarised society, both in Israel and in the UK. So many of us have had some core beliefs shattered. Some of us are carrying deep scars, while others are pushing ‘solutions’ that re-open or infect those scars. It is a time when so many are in some kind of visceral pain, which might well be moral injury.
When one person’s extreme hurt and upset is caused by the actions of someone acting from their own place of extreme hurt, we have the worst case of ‘an eye for an eye’ making the whole world blind. Over four months on from 7th October, the situation is not calming down anytime soon.
The important step now for us, therefore, is to calm ourselves down as best we can. This begins with the first steps of addressing moral injury, which is to acknowledge to ourselves and each other the nature and extent of how we feel our values have been transgressed.
This requires us to be willing to speak of our own hurt AND to be willing to hear someone else’s hurt. It takes strength to open up about our own hurt, just as it takes strength to hear and acknowledge someone else’s hurt.
We might only be able to go one step further at this time, which is to accept how challenging and distressing it is when moral truths that we held dear are threatened or damaged.
It’s best not to think much further than this. Neither you nor I, nor our Muslim fellow citizens, can solve the current crisis in the Middle East, but if we can listen to each other’s hurt, then we can affirm each other’s humanity. Dayeynu - That would be enough!
0 Comments