Happy New Year, But Only If We Make It That!
January 2, 2025

As New Year’s Eve moved by the passing of successive seconds past midnight, people around the world wished each other a “Happy New Year!” It’s a lovely sentiment and I’ve said it or written it many times over either side of that midnight when the calendar ticks over.

However, if we wish to turn this wish into a reality, we have to move from ritual words into practical action. We URGENTLY NEED to turn the wish into reality, for so many compelling reasons. Let me just give you one.

One of my rabbinic colleagues has recently received vile abuse from Jews living in this country. Here are three of the ‘milder’ examples:

“May you be deported to Gaza and thrown off a tall building by Hamas.”

“I’m sure your mother wished she aborted you.”

“Liberal Judaism or whatever you call your strain is not real Judaism. You are not a rabbi, and probably not a Jew either.”

Others include death threats aimed at the rabbi or their children. Some of the abuse is coming from members of Progressive synagogues!

Our national society is moving, in line with trends we can see elsewhere, to sharper polarisation, with sides refusing to even listen to the other side’s views. We know that tensions within Jewish communities have been strained, sometimes beyond breaking point, as people have different views about the conflict between Israel and Hamas in Gaza, other groups in the Middle East, including Hezbollah and the Houthis, and the Palestinians of the West Bank.

I can often feel pulled towards more extreme responses to some of the most extreme verbal and physical abuse perpetrated by others. What might I wish to say or do to those who have abused and made the vilest threats to my rabbinic colleague, simply because he expresses different views to them? Those moments of anger pass quickly, but I am still left struggling for an adequate response.

Jewish tradition offers a few helpful thoughts. In the first place, the Talmud explains why Jewish law generally follows the opinions of the House of Hillel. This is not just because they were generally more lenient, but also because the disciples of Hillel were gentle and modest, studied both their own opinions and the opinions of the other school, and humbly mentioned the words of the other school before their own.

A few hundred years later, in the Midrash on the Book of Psalms, Rabbi Yannai is cited as saying, “The Torah was not given in a clear-cut manner. Rather, on every matter of purity or impurity, God would offer forty-nine reasons why the matter could be pure and forty-nine reasons why the matter could be impure. The matter could only be decided after discussion by the majority vote.”

The big challenge implicit in both the above models is that a lot of listening has to be done before the decision, whether by vote or other means, is taken. We saw an exceptional example of this in the parliamentary debate on the “Terminally Ill Adults (End of Life) Bill” put forward by Kim Leadbeater MP. In a full House of Commons, with many compelling speeches, members listened respectfully prior to voting. If only more debates could be like this!

Modern-day models of conflict resolution follow similar principles. Harvard Law School’s Program on Negotiation, whose principles underpinned the Camp David Accords between Israel and Egypt in 1979, suggest that in any conflict, if participants become problem solvers and listen to learn each other’s interests, then solutions that work for both / all parties can be found.

When talking about Difficult Conversations, they suggest, “In addition to your story and the other person’s story, every difficult conversation includes an invisible Third Story. The Third Story is the one a keen observer would tell, someone with no stake in your particular problem… Think like a mediator: One of the most helpful tools a mediator has is the ability to identify this invisible Third Story.”¹

If we want to truly make our wishes of “Happy New Year!” to become reality then, in any sphere of our lives, we would do well to listen to people with whom we disagree, explore their interests and share our own until it might become possible to identify and, ideally, co-create a Third Story.

Further, when we are faced with people who might use the sort of language I cited above, then our challenge is to separate the person, to whom we might be kind, from their words, about which we must be respectfully intolerant. Maybe we need to be braver in exploring what has driven them to such extreme and violent language, with the aim of helping them to renounce such hateful speech.

Psalm 34 includes one of the most powerful guiding principles in the Hebrew Bible:

“Which of you are eager for life and desire years of good fortune? Guard your tongue from evil and your lips from deceitful speech. Shun evil and do good, seek amity and pursue it.”

May we play our part in making this a year in which more people can live happily, by seeking amity – cordial relationships, peaceful speech and actions – each and every day.

Rabbi Richard Jacobi

¹Stone, Patton, Heen, Difficult Conversations, Harvard Negotiation Project, 1999, Chapter 8, “Getting Started: Begin from the Third Story,” pp. 149–150.

0 Comments