I’m writing this on Tisha B’Av, about which Rabbi David wrote last week. I’m also looking forward to this Friday evening’s special Bat Mitzvah service for Renée Hart taking place at Clore Tikva School, and beyond that to Tu B’Av – a Jewish celebration of love next Monday.
Why am I connecting all these three events? There is an essential journey for us to take to get beyond hate, both that which is directed at us and that which we might feel. Hate is understood to be a response to fears we feel, and though it isn’t the only possible response to fear, it is sometimes the easiest or most accessible. Fears sometimes arise from our prejudices and our ignorance. One example is when people who are different to us come to live near or among us. They can be seen as an “out-group”, distinct and separate from our own circle, our “in-group”.
If we take an honest look at some of the texts of Torah, we will find that it often creates an “in-group” of the Israelites and several “out-groups”, typically “the Canaanites, the Amorites, the Hittites, the Perizzites, the Hivites, and the Jebusites” (Ex. 33:2 and other places). They were groups to be feared, as they would compromise the ‘purity’ of the Israelites in serving God. As the Bible stories develop, the tensions and battles between the Israelites and these other tribes are a recurring theme.
Tisha B’Av, with its origins in commemorating the fall of both Temples, widened its scope over the centuries to encompass the all-too-many pogroms that befell the Jewish people. Whether at the hands of crusaders in the eleventh or twelfth centuries, whether prompted by the ‘Blood Libel’ here in Norwich, Lincoln and elsewhere, or caused by other forms of prejudice, Jews were seen as an “out-group” to be feared. The fear often morphed into violent hatred.
For all the progress since biblical and medieval times, these same themes have been dominating the news cycles over the past few weeks. Fears have been stoked about new “out-groups”, using terms like “refugees”, “asylum seekers”, “illegal migrants” or simply “immigrants”, and so on. It took one tragedy, but it could have been anything, to turn the fears into hatred and rioting.
As Jews, we know of old, through Tisha B’Av, and we know afresh since 7th October 2023, that hatred causes loss of lives, injuries, grief and, sadly, retaliation and an escalating cycle of violence.
Here, in the UK these past few days, we have seen components of the antidote to this dreadful cycle. Peaceful gatherings that emphasise hope are part of this, especially as they included people from diverse backgrounds and various faiths.
Hope is integral to the pattern of the day of Tisha B’Av. Those who observe the full day – I’m not among their number – will note an upswing in the afternoon towards hope and belief that redemption and better times will come. Such beliefs can be taught, and they can also be fostered by inter-group relations, so our “in-group” becomes wider and more diverse.
The “in-group” of our synagogue is beautifully diverse and we rightly celebrate the wide variety of people who are in our synagogue community. Each family that celebrates a life cycle event in our community brings their own uniqueness, and this will be true on Friday evening. So do come and join the ELELS community in a special Erev Shabbat service that will include Renée leyning (chanting) from the Torah. Renée’s Hebrew name – Rinah – means ‘joy’ and the service will include much joy and give much reason for hope.
And finally, if we can move ourselves from fear and hate towards hope, we open up the possibility for love, as in “Love your neighbour as yourself” (Leviticus 19:18) and / or the romantic love of Tu B’Av. Jewish tradition sees the 15th day of Av as a day of match-making that took place during the harvest season. Nowadays, in Israel and around the Jewish world, it is a celebration of loving relationships. Some of these loving relationships straddle boundaries and show us that love truly can conquer all!
Let’s take some time over this Shabbat to acknowledge what fears we might be carrying, and to name them, so that we might take hope-inspired steps to replace fear and hate with hope and some form of love.
See you on Friday evening or on Saturday morning when we can reinforce each other’s hope, joy and love!
Shabbat shalom,
Rabbi Richard Jacobi
0 Comments