Freedom and Responsibility
March 30, 2023

I’m writing this in the middle of the only court case for which I shall be a juror. The time waiting to be on a jury and now while on a case has given me good reason to reflect on democracy and its requirements. Both here in the UK and in Israel, the ways in which a democracy operates through checks and balances are justifiably under scrutiny right now.

Last Friday, I was pleased to join the demonstration on Whitehall in support of democracy in Israel. It was led by many Israelis who live in the UK who want to feel proud of their country, but fear the changes proposed by the new coalition government would remove important safeguards of a genuine democracy.

No elected government can simply do whatever it wishes once it has a simple majority in a parliament. It has to be accountable between elections for the legitimacy of its actions. Similarly, we as individuals have freedoms we should cherish, and these have to be balanced by our responsibilities to each other and to the world. No-one can or should ever just do what they want without accountability.

As we approach Pesach, which we celebrate as the season of our freedom, we learn anew each year of the struggle to attain freedom and that, pretty quickly, the Israelites learned the need for a system of rules and laws to guide words and deeds, and ensure all could enjoy responsibly the benefits that freedom brings.

Being a juror means helping to decide whether someone has broken the law and so should have some of their freedoms taken away. It feels like a heavy responsibility, which it is, and I’m aware that all twelve of us are taking it very seriously, as indeed we should.

This feels like an important duty, as part of making democracy and the rule of law operate. It is by no means a perfect system, but any quibbles I might have should not distract me from its purpose. I am helping this week to make democracy work.

Our synagogue is also a democracy, run by its members for the common good of us all. It needs ideally every member to contribute towards its good health and effectiveness but, at present, too few are actively doing so.

Soon after Pesach, we will be asking more members to contribute to the wellbeing of the ELELS community. I know you will help make our community a place of freedom with responsibility – please consider dropping me a note with suggestions for how you will help or to start a conversation. I can be reached at rabbi@elels.org.uk and look forward to hearing from you.

In the meantime, I wish you a Chag Pesach Sameach – a joyful celebration of Pesach! I look forward to seeing you at our Pesach services or at the always special Communal Seder!

Rabbi Richard Jacobi

0 Comments