This message is hitting your inbox on Maundy Thursday, an important date in Holy Week, culminating with Easter Sunday, which marks the foundational event in Christianity. This is one of the rare years in which Easter, as marked in the Western churches, and Pesach are a month apart. If you’re wondering why, read on!
As you may know, all Jewish festivals are fixed by a Jewish calendar, which was developed in 359 CE by Rabbi Hillel Nesiyah. It used a cycle of 19 years, with a leap month in 7 out of the nineteen, with the aim of keeping every festival, but especially Pesach in its proper season (in the northern hemisphere!). This amazing feat of applied scientific knowledge has worked well for nearly 1700 years!
Indeed, when researching this article, I discovered from the website of the Royal Museums Greenwich that the 19-year pattern is known as the Metonic cycle in which the phases of the moon repeat exactly!
This year is a Jewish calendar leap year, which is why there were two months between Tu BiShevat and Purim. It also means that Pesach and all following festivals and Yamim Tovim (special days) seem to come very late this year, as our minds are anchored to the Gregorian calendar. Pesach is, as always, beginning as the evening comes and the Jewish calendar rolls over to 15th Nisan – this year Monday 22nd April.
In contrast, let’s look at the two Easters and when they are celebrated. For the Catholic Church, and its practice is shared by other western-based churches, there is a formula for calculating Easter, which links the solar Gregorian calendar to the lunar cycle. This formula states that Easter Sunday is to be the first Sunday after the full moon that occurs on or after the Spring equinox, now set by the Church as 21st March for this purpose.
So, this year, the full moon after the Spring Equinox was last Monday, hence Easter in this country will be marked by most Christians this weekend. Though Maundy Thursday is seen as the day of the ‘Last Supper’ often suggested as being a Passover Meal, this year it is four weeks away from Erev Pesach!
In contrast, the Eastern Orthodox churches will mark Easter according to the Julian calendar, named after Julius Caesar. This often sees Easter one, four or five weeks after the Gregorian calendar date. In 2024, they are five weeks apart, in 2025, they actually fall on the same date! Orthodox Easter will always fall after Pesach, by deliberate decision of the Council of Nicaea in 325 CE.
Why does this matter to us? Firstly, I think we can take pride in the genius of fourth century Rabbi Hillel Nesiya! Secondly, I think it is good for us to know about the festivals and special times of the people around us, so we can greet them appropriately. Thirdly, you might now have answers to some of the more esoteric quiz questions you might be asked! Or, like me, you might be able to explain to your Greek Orthodox barber how his Easter is calculated!
There is a fourth reason, which is perhaps most important. The historical character we know as Jesus was born, lived and died as a Jew. He was a radical, a progressive in his time, and therefore earned disapproval from those in power, both Jewish and Roman. Remember, the Second Temple in Jerusalem was the focus of Jewish life at that time and Jesus criticised its leaders for what he saw as corruption (no such things happen among those in power nowadays, do they!!).
The stories of the gospels, part history, part theology, part polemic, began what eventually evolved into Christianity. The arguments between those who believed in Jesus as the Messiah and son of God, on the one hand, and those who continued to believe and practise Judaism, on the other, also led to some of the first anti-Jewish violence and discrimination. They sowed the seeds of what we generally now call antisemitism, but is better described as anti-Jewish hatred. Easter often became a focus for such hatred, linked to the suggestion that Jews contributed to the crucifixion of Jesus.
Sadly, nearly two thousand years after Jesus lived and died, this hatred often reappears. Knowledgeable Christians will disown and condemn such thoughts, words and deeds. We can look to them as allies and, here at ELELS, we will be continuing to build friendships with them in coming months and years.
Shabbat shalom,
Rabbi Richard Jacobi
0 Comments