I didn’t want to be writing about this, but I feel that events have given me no choice.
As many of you know, and some of you witnessed, last Sunday afternoon Rabbis Charley Baginsky and Josh Levy were stopped from completing their prepared speech to the march and rally held in support of the release and return of all remaining hostages held in Gaza by Hamas and its allies.
As the News Editor for The Jewish News, Justin Cohen, subsequently wrote, “The truth is that not a word of what Rabbi Baginsky and Rabbi Levy said would be out of place at the weekly rally for the hostages in Tel Aviv.” So, why were my colleagues not allowed to complete their speech?
At one level, the answer has to do with the origins of Sunday’s march, which began with two organisations at the opposite end of the religious / political spectrum to us, the National Jewish Assembly (founder Gary Mond was ejected from the Board of Deputies for Islamophobic comments) and Stop The Hate (founder Yochy Davis was previously disciplined by the Board of Deputies for calling the Union of Jewish Students “leftist scum”). The irony has not been lost that our Co-CEO’s were stopped from advocating for peace by people wearing “Stop The Hate” tee-shirts! (see image below)
The march expanded to become almost cross-communal, with all major organisations and
denominations supporting it. Its focus was subtly shifted so that all organisations could support the
event, though a key theme for some speakers remained to lambast the UK government for considering
the recognition of Palestine while the hostages are still held in Gaza. Critically, stewarding remained
with Stop The Hate, when it possibly should have been handed over to CST. This is a main reason why
the shouting and heckling was not curbed and the episode escalated as it did.
Arguably and ironically, the fact that there has been national and international outrage at the silencing of Rabbis Josh and Charley has meant that their speech has been heard or read by many more people
than its original audience.
So, if the above is my commentary on the events, and you can easily find others, what is the important
message for us?
Fundamentally, if we support free speech within the parameters set out by law, as I would hope we all do, then those who intervened to prevent the two rabbinic CEO’s from completing their speech have to
be condemned for their actions. Further, as the Board of Deputies’ statement suggested, they and
those who aggressively shouted abuse during the incomplete speech need to reflect on their actions,
which contradicted core Jewish values that advocate for machloket l’sheim shamayim – arguments for
the sake of heaven.
We are free to disagree about how best to bring home all the remaining hostages, but only by listening
to each other and considering the merits of their ideas can we hope to find the wisest solutions. Across
any spectrum, be that political, religious, cultural, social, or any other, it is only by considering what
others say on its merits that we can learn and grow.
May we, within ELELS, continue to disagree agreeably and also to agree humbly, always ready to
change our views when someone gives us just cause so to do. Whatever the temperature, may we
never become hot-headed or entrenched defensively in our positions, but remain open-minded
seekers, as our Judaism demands, of truth, justice and peace.
Rabbi Richard Jacobi

0 Comments