These famous words, from the Book of Kohelet (Ecclesiastes) are part of a longer poem about the ups and downs of life. Superficially, they suggest an equivalence between each of the opposites, but I have been struck especially in recent days, by the reality of how much that is not the case here.
Whether we focus on the term as England’s Men’s Team Manager spent by Gareth Southgate or the challenges being addressed by the new government; whether we think locally about how we build our community or how we nurture the talents of children and young adults, breaking down can be done in an instant, building up takes time, patience and skill. Sowing competitive division in a group, a team, a community, or a country, or practising ‘divide and rule’, can seem a tempting way to get results, but it is always counter-productive over the medium to long term.
We know there are some people who will never forgive Gareth Southgate for not managing the team to a victory in the Euros final, either in 2021 or this month. We know there are lots of people who think they know better than him how to manage England’s men. The arrogance of ignorance is a blight on any and every society, and the vile language and threats used are destructive. There is, I’m sure a direct link between these rude people – mainly men – and the shameful and horrifying statistics about the rise in domestic violence when England’s men lose a tournament match.
Breaking things or people can be done in a second; it takes years to build individuals and teams, communities and organisations like our synagogue. Gareth Southgate practised an integrity-based approach to management, built on honesty and genuine care for every individual. He changed the culture of the squads so that everyone played their part, no matter how small, whether playing on the pitch or not. He led the building of a community that got so close to winning, when for decades none of the higher profile managers had succeeded anywhere near as much. The silver medals they earned are better than 22 other teams that participated in the Euros!
It's easy to knock him, but a better response from us all would be to appreciate and learn from him about how to treat people, how to handle pressure with dignity, and how to teach co-operation and collaboration. His style and approach fits with the Jewish values we teach and seek to live out in our ELELS community.
Indeed, we have many people who share the values shown by Gareth Southgate and who seek to help us build the community. At the AGM eleven days ago, we thanked, in particular, Stewart Spivack and Elliott Porte who have stepped down after long service on Council. Both continue to help in other ways, and Elliott is leading the service this Shabbat morning.
We always need new people to become part of the large team of volunteers – every contribution, small or large, helps to build our community. Between now and the High Holy Days, we will be asking more of you to take part in building a stronger, more engaged and active community. Please consider what you can do to help.
Rabbi Richard Jacobi
0 Comments