This evening sees the 85th anniversary of the November Pogrom, also known as Kristallnacht. This weekend sees the United Kingdom and many other countries marking the cessation of hostilities to end the Great War of 1914 – 1918, which we now, sadly, call the First World War.
We remember a pogrom and a war at a time when we last month experienced the newest and most egregious pogrom and while the physical or spiritual home of almost all Jews – the State of Israel – is at war with Hamas. This is a time when we realise that Henry Ford was unfortunately correct when he stated “The only thing we learn from history is that we don’t learn from history.”
Over many years, survivors of the Nazi period, my father among them, have bravely given their testimony about the cruelties and privations they experienced. We who listened to them often shared their hope that there would “Never Again” be such atrocities.
Now, very sadly, there are many new people whose testimony about brutality we will need to hear over coming months and years. It will be painful for them to talk and it will also be painful for us to hear. However, it is our duty to bear witness to those who suffered, to support them when they speak, and to listen actively and with compassion.
Part of being human is to provide care and support for each other, especially when people are hurting. If we can listen attentively and with care to their experience of pain and loss, then perhaps we can move forward with them towards a reconciliation.
The last two paragraphs you have just read apply equally to testimony from our fellow Jews and from civilians in Gaza. The time will come when we will need to listen to both. Right now, this might not be possible for the tellers or for the listeners – everything is too raw. However, I hope we will start preparing now for times of testimony giving, bearing witness and working towards peace and reconciliation.
Nonetheless, on Friday night, we will remember the experiences of our fellow Jews who lived through Kristallnacht. On Saturday morning, we will add Remembrance into our service, at the eleventh hour of the eleventh day of the eleventh month, and when we take time to hear from Martin Sugarman about his work with AJEX (the Association of Jewish Ex-servicepeople).
Listening to pain, whether from the Torah stories of the Israelite people in slavery, or from past wars and conflicts, or from current or very recent events, is difficult but necessary. We can pray all we like for peace, but until we, and many others, are willing to do the hard work involved in making peace possible, it will remain an unfulfilled hope.
Rabbi Abraham Joshua Heschel famously stated, “I am, in spite of my better judgement, an optimist.” We have to retain belief in the possibility of peace between Israel and its neighbours, and we have to be willing to do the hard work of turning hope and belief into reality. As Theodor Herzl himself stated, “If you will it, it is no dream.”
Rabbi Richard Jacobi
0 Comments