Mah Nishtanah? Why Is This A Pesach Like No Recent Other?
April 18, 2024

This is the time when Jews all around the world are preparing for Pesach – inviting relatives and friends to a seder, shopping, cooking in advance, sourcing horseradish, and so on. Survey after survey, generation after generation, the Pesach seder has the highest rate of participation around the Jewish world.

Of course, not everyone follows a full service, with all the rituals of the night. But the overwhelming majority of Jews, wherever they are, recreate some part of the story of the Exodus from Egypt. The story that begins in slavery and degradation, ends with freedom and rejoicing.

Except this year! Almost every Jew I know or talk to is feeling that this year is different. When we talk about the slavery and the imprisonment of the early story, then we can link to those in captivity and especially the 134 hostages still held by Hamas.

But how can we proceed via the ten drops of wine that reduce our joy as we recall the plagues to the celebrations of the latter part of the seder?

Firstly, we will find ways to acknowledge the pain felt by the hostages and their families. I find the sheer number of innovative rituals and readings overwhelming! I will choose one or two of these for us to share at the Communal Seder, and I also encourage you to find some way to acknowledge the plight of the hostages and, if you wish, the tragic loss of life around the region.

One rabbi suggests that we should have two matzot instead of three under or in the matzah cloth. (Click here to read more.) Various rabbis and teachers have added ideas and material to Ritualwell.org and this article by Adva Chattler might interest you.

Secondly, though, continuing through to the end of the seder, and singing the songs with usual joy and laughter, makes an important statement about being Jewish. We retain hope, even when rational minds might tell us there is none. We retain the determination that Judaism and Jewishness will endure whatever twists and turns the current conflict might take.

I hope we will also commit to ourselves and each other to strengthen our community, to increase our positive influence on the world around us. I hope that we will determine that our role is to bring the world closer to the vision of our prayers, so that we play our part in bringing everyone out of their ‘mitzrayim’ – their narrow straits or place of confinement.

Then we bring honour to the name of Jew by our own good conduct!

I wish you a Pesach in which we appreciate fully the joys of freedom and seek to enable more people to share in those joys!

Rabbi Richard Jacobi

0 Comments