Who Do You Think You Are?
January 4, 2024

We’re all familiar with the BBC programme of that name and the journeys of discovery that famous people go on to discover more about their roots. I was struck this week, as I taught the Access to Judaism class about identity and status, and as I previewed our Torah portion for this Shabbat, by some other meanings to this question.

Remember, as this week’s Torah reading tells us, we were slaves in Egypt, who left in a hurry after the tenth plague had struck, but who only believed in God after crossing the Sea of Reeds, with a wall of water on either side that then engulfed the Egyptian army.

Firstly, we can see this question in opposition to a second query, namely “Who do other people think you are?” Given that we all have our blind spots, the answers provided by those people might be insightful. However, in the current febrile atmosphere around Israel – Gaza, there might also be stereotypes and harsh judgements involved in how other people see us. This might serve to remind us to be careful about how we might pre-judge others.

Secondly, we could read the question as aspirational, a sort of visualising as if we are already the person we aspire to be. Just as sportspeople seek to visualise what it will be like when they have won, so we might picture the better version of ourselves. This might help any new year’s resolutions become reality!

Finally, you might hear that critical parental rhetorical “WHO DO YOU THINK YOU ARE?!” The putdown from an elder or better suggests we are not as important or grown up as we might have thought.

When exploring Jewish identity, there is a fascinating range of possible components. The model I teach originated with a Dutch Jewish Professor, Ido Abram, who argues that there are five possible components, about which we might ask questions:

A: The Jewish religion, culture and tradition – to what extent am I a religious or observant Jew, who values the special times and days of the Jewish calendar, prayer and communal worship?

B: Israel, love of Zion and Zionism – what is the role of Israel as a concept and the State of Israel as a reality in how I see myself?

C: The Shoah and antisemitism, persecution and survival – what is the importance of the Shoah generally, as well as specifically to my own family?

D: The person’s own life story – how much is my identity shaped by my parents’ stories, my family, and my own life to date?

E: The local / national culture and surroundings – what role does living in the UK and how long I’ve lived here play in my identity?

All five of the above are not equally important to me, but they each contribute something to who I think I am. I know that every member of the ELELS community has their own combination of these five, with some people having 0% in one or more areas. No one combination is correct or better than another – there is no ideal or perfect Jew.

May we journey through this year enjoying and respecting our own and other people’s identities, remembering that we are all “in the image of God”.

Rabbi Richard Jacobi

0 Comments