A Time To Keep Silence and a Time To Speak (Kohelet)
October 19, 2023

Two evenings ago, I took part in a one-hour silent vigil in Higham’s Park, which was the initiative of a Muslim woman, Faiza Shaheen. Over the course of an hour about ninety people stopped, some for the whole hour, and others for part of it, “to think of the victims, to reflect in whatever way you feel comfortable and to show our empathy and connection with all those hurting at this time.”

 

It was very moving to be with two Christian leaders and a Muslim leader, alongside Rabbi Lev Taylor. We all helped Faiza to hold the solemn and silent space, and those attending felt we had affirmed community here in our area. The power was in the silence – speeches, flags and emblems were banned – and we only spoke words of peace in three languages after the hour concluded.

 

There have been many other times over the past ten days when silence has been condemned as showing a lack of support for us as Jews when we have been hurting as a large family following the murders of so many people of all ages on Simchat Torah. We wanted people to speak to us, to say that they appreciated just how heinous the acts of terror had been, to show they cared.

 

We also wanted people to be willing to speak out, so that we weren’t alone in condemning acts of barbaric nastiness. I won’t go into specific detail here, because it’s unnecessary, which is also another aspect of knowing when enough has been said or enough detail has been given.

 

Judaism, generally speaking, does not do silence very well. In our services, we prefer to produce liturgies of great artistry, containing thousands of words. Yet, some of the most meaningful moments for people come in the time and space between spoken or read words, in the still calm that allows us, perhaps, to discern what is the good and right thing to do or say.

 

Over these last twelve days, too many words have been spoken or shared too hastily and too angrily, only stoking the fires of enmity and hate. Some words have been shared without checking the veracity of what has been passed on, spreading gossip and panic and fear. Some words have been spoken to provoke or to intimidate, to bully or to manipulate.

 

“If you can keep your head when all about are losing theirs and blaming it on you …” wrote Rudyard Kipling about 130 years ago. His words are tremendously relevant to our situation now. We have to keep our heads, and this might require us to be silent until we can make sure that what we say in spoken or written form might be truthful, factual, and kind. There is indeed a ‘time to keep silence and a time to speak.’

 

Better still, when we speak, if we can use our words to save lives and not harm them, then the wisdom of Judaism will support us – “whoever saves a single human life, it is as if they have saved an entire world.” So say both the Talmud (tractate Sanhedrin) and the Koran (Sura 5:32).

 

Rabbi Richard Jacobi

 

PS Come and join us at Marlborough Road this Saturday morning for our Shelanu service – fewer words and a little more time to reflect and think.

0 Comments