Avoiding False Prophets
June 30, 2022

As a Liberal rabbi, I would never claim the right to dictate to you how you should speak or act. I would also hope that no-one would ever become an unthinking disciple following my words or 'teachings’.

Our Torah portion on Saturday warns us against following false prophets, who might tempt the people to worship other gods. The words for these people used in the Hebrew are navi and cholem chalom. The latter phrase literally means a ‘dreamer of dreams’, but is usually understood as a dream interpreter. The first word excites commentators, many of whom see the word as meaning a “speaker” or “announcer” - someone who should be conveying God’s teachings, but might simply be promoting their own message.

Taking this meaning on board, we have a chapter that is warning us against charismatic speakers, who might seem to be proposing wonderful things, but who really are promoting themselves and their own interests.  It is warning us against following those who make big promises, but who will not deliver a reality that matches the standards of Torah’s highest themes. In other words, we have to learn how to avoid being drawn in by seductive messages.

Our twenty-first century world throws thousands of seductive messages at us each day - advertisements everywhere, peddlers of attractive or comforting lies rather than uncomfortable truths. The challenge has never been greater for us to discern the difference between truth and deception.

Back in the times of the Torah’s compilation, its authors believed that the teachings and stories of Torah would serve to give its adherents - the Jews - the moral compass and training to be able to tell the difference between truths and lies. Here in the twenty-first century of the Common Era, we need more than ever to discuss, debate, differ with each other about what our Judaism requires of us. Through such debates, we sharpen our minds, clarify and improve our thinking and our reasoning, and use differences to help us discern between truths and lesser truths, which sometimes cross the line into being lies.

I will never expect anyone to do as I say just because I am a rabbi. I will never expect anyone to treat what I say as right, just because I am a rabbi. I will always expect every member of this synagogue, every individual with whom I am in dialogue, to offer their alternative propositions so that we can both find out which has greater merit. I aim never to yield to force or pressure, but to give way when someone has expounded better principles and sounder applications of them to the real world. This, to me, is the essence of Progressive Judaism. Please come argue (politely) with me!

Shabbat shalom

Rabbi Richard Jacobi

 

0 Comments