"Jewish People should avoid criticising Israel, because anti-Zionism supports antisemitism"
We are trialling a debate column in our weekly updates a few times over the next few months on topical subjects, with members presenting perspectives on a contentious topic. Do feel free to comment!
Miriam Greenwood writes:
In the May 2021 HaGesher an article referred to something I had written for the magazine previously as 'antisemitic'. (See 'A response to Miriam Greenwood's letter published in January edition of HaGesher'.) This was very upsetting to me and without foundation and so I am exercising my right of reply. I will do this by breaking down the issue into three parts:
- What makes something antisemitic?
- How does the question of anti-Zionism fit in?
- What was in the original article that caused the disagreement and why is it important?
With so much in the media in recent years about antisemitism, a few years ago I decided to go into the subject for myself. First, I did a project on antisemitism in England and Britain from the medieval period up to and including the Second World War for presentation to a Jewish group. In 2019 I undertook the Birkbeck College course 'Facing Antisemitism: Politics, Culture and History' under Professor David Feldman.
Antisemitism refers to anti-Jewish prejudice, discrimination and, at the worst, physical attacks on people or property; it involves negative stereotypes which are hard to dislodge, false beliefs such as 'Judeo-Bolshevik conspiracy' and Holocaust denial. In recent years, there has been an attempt in some quarters to equate criticism of Israel with antisemitism which is highly contested and difficult to reconcile with the principle of free speech.
In this context and with this complexity, how does an antisemitism label come to be attached to me? The accusation was combined with a reference to anti-Zionism, so was it to do with that?
Opposition to the idea of Zionism is as old as Zionist thought itself: from the outset there was anti-Zionism in the Jewish communities where these ideas began to be discussed in the late nineteenth century. Much of this was religiously based on the principle that the return to the Zion of prayers will and should be under the aegis of moshiach, in God's own time, not something for humans to accomplish by themselves. Other objections were political because those struggling for emancipation, equal rights for Jews in the countries where we are a minority, thought this goal should be the priority and campaigning for it would be weakened by Zionism. So being non-Zionist or anti-Zionist is very Jewish. Over time, these positions and thoughts have changed and developed, deeply affected of course by the Holocaust and then the establishment and history of Israel. With the latter, the position of Palestinians became central and over time anti-Zionism became understood as opposition to the particular form of Zionism which the Israeli state has pursued, one exemplified by the ultra-nationalist 2018 Nation-State Law as well as by the oppression of Palestinians in the occupied territories. If, like me, you have close relatives in Israel, these developments are all the more distressing. Although in a minority, there are many Jews both inside and outside Israel who oppose these developments and the version of Zionism which has motivated them. Thus anti-Zionism is a perfectly normal position for Jews to take and I reject any suggestion that it could be considered antisemitic.
But what is anti-Zionist about my writing that 'Arab Jews left countries including Egypt, Iraq and Yemen under varying circumstances which certainly included persecutions, but also often involved Zionist promotion'? This has genuinely flabbergasted me. Supporters of the creation of a Jewish state have naturally promoted their views and this occurred in Arab-Muslim countries as well as in Jewish communities elsewhere. Where permitted in certain countries and during certain periods, they encouraged aliya, and in addition to some underground operations there were official airlifts to Israel from Iraq and Yemen. (My information comes from the fully referenced Wikipedia article 'Jewish exodus from Arab and Muslim countries'.)
The key point is that Jewish migrants to Israel were accepted, indeed welcomed, as potential citizens. This was very different to the situation of Palestinians in 1948 who were driven out of areas which became part of the new Israeli state and ended up in refugee camps in surrounding countries which did not want them and where their descendants live to this day. Why make this point? The reason is that an equivalence was drawn by Ben-Dror Yemini when he spoke at our shul in a Friday evening service in February 2020 during which he went so far as to call what happened an exchange of populations. Subsequently, a similar position was put forward by the current Israeli Ambassador to the UK, Tzipi Hotovely, when she was interviewed during last year's Limmud. The supposed equivalence is intended to downplay the significance of what Palestinians experienced as the outcome of 1948 events and to deny the continuing status of the Palestinian refugees as such.
There are two important conclusions: First I would urge everyone to reflect carefully before calling someone or some piece of writing you disagree with 'antisemitic'; remember what antisemitic oppression of Jews has really meant over the centuries. Secondly, in an age of disinformation (which has helped foster antisemitic conspiracies) I urge everyone to base their views on knowledge of and truthfulness about Jewish history, whether dealing with religious, cultural and political developments in Eastern European Jewish communities or with the development of modern Israel.
John Morrison writes:
There is a difference between ‘criticising Israel’ and ‘anti-Zionism’.
Genuine criticism both constructive and negative from the diaspora Jewish communities and others is only to be expected and debated and should not be considered Anti-Zionist.
Most people accept that Israel is the only truly democratic country in the region – and like all democracies its society has never been perfect. Its people endure many of the same societal problems faced by most western counties, including issues relating to migration and refugees, and should be open to the same criticisms that Western Governments are.
However, Israel`s critics should not apply double standards by requiring of it a behaviour not expected or demanded of any other democratic nation, and this criticism becomes Anti-Zionism when those who are making the arguments are motivated by trying to deny the right of the state of Israel to exist.
Whilst as Jews we do not need Wikipedia to define Anti-Semitism or Anti-Zionism it is worth noting that Wikipedia states Anti-Zionism is opposition to Zionism. The term is broadly defined in the modern era as opposition to the existence of the State of Israel or, prior to 1948, its establishment as well as to the political movement of Jews to self-determination.
The Jewish Anti-Zionist argument lost all credibility OVER 70 YEARS AGO with the establishment of the State of Israel in 1948.
Anti-Semites need no excuses for their dislike and hatred of Jews but they are very often EMBOLDENED in their nasty activities by Jewish Anti-Zionists who whilst thankfully few in number, are very vociferous in their activities and actions.