The Big Debate #1- Does a synagogue need a building?
November 23, 2021

We’re going to be trialling a debate column in this weekly update a few times over the next few months on topical subjects, with members arguing in favour or against, and the first one is today. Do feel free to comment!

Does a Synagogue need a Building?

Yes – Ben Glassman

Two years ago, to be provocative, we might have debated whether a synagogue congregation needed to meet physically to form a synagogue or whether a community could exist purely online. 18 months ago we put that to the test! We now know that some are happy to join services online but others much less so. We know that, although cheder and events can be held online, many members wanted to be back in a building, mixing in person. Things may change over time but for now the question is less ‘do we need a building’ and more ‘do we want our own building’. In other words – to buy or to rent.

Short term contracts can be helpful – they allow us to be adaptable (many of us choose contracts with phones for example) but it’s intentionally temporary – keeping loyalties light so that we can change when the opportunity comes. Not the kind of thing you’d plan to build memories around.

To ask whether a synagogue needs a building isn’t too different to asking whether a family needs a permanent home. In many ways it’s a very inefficient use of space. At least pre-Pandemic, family homes were empty a lot of the time (especially if you disregard the time when we’re asleep). In young households, everyone is out at school or work on weekdays, and taking part in a social activities (or going to Shul!) at the weekend...but would we be happier just living out of hotels instead? Not in the least. It’s a lifestyle some people live but not one that many envy.

Most people now start out renting their homes when they first live independently – for reasons of affordability but also because they aren’t sure where they want to live long term. Overtime, however, most people want to have a fixed place of their own – and synagogues go through a similar journey. At first communities are happy to hire spaces and try things out as they gather new members – if you’re not sure how many members the shul will have, what your budget is likely to become, or what your members’ priorities are, it seems unwise to be settling down straightaway. But once those things are known it’s more comfortable to find a fixed location – somewhere you can decorate and make our own, drop into without notice, hold events at any time during the week, keep treasured items without worry, never having to worry about negotiating a timeslot with a landowner or worrying what to do when a contract runs out. The difficulties we’ve had finding a suitable site for the HHDs over the past few years is testament to the stress and challenges that a rented space can lead to.

It's not that we need to be tied to a building – we hold events in members’ homes, at rented sites for big services…even outdoors for social activities – but ultimately most of us want a permanent home to call our own.

No – Bob Kamall

In answer to the question, does a synagogue need a building, I would argue no it doesn’t.

To determine if a building is necessary let’s ask what is it used for, when is it used, and who uses it?

A synagogue has many purposes – including worship, learning, communal events, and as a place of work.

As a place of worship, it is only used on Friday evenings, Saturday mornings, and some other festival services. Only a small minority attend services on a regular basis; High Holy Days are the exception, but these are usually held at other venues – so communal worship does not need a sanctuary in a synagogue building.

As a place of learning, Cheder on Saturday mornings and adult education on one or two evenings per week but not every week of the year. Cheder and other forms of learning are used by sub-groups of the community. While it’s nice to have classrooms with related facilities, Cheder and adult learning does not need a synagogue building.

Communal events are more sporadic covering a diverse range of activities and the widest variety of audiences, including guests of the community. Sometimes (for example, communal Seders) it is the synagogue building that either restricts numbers attending or the activities offered; so, these are better served away from the synagogue building.

Oddly enough, synagogue buildings are most regularly used as places of work; five days a week for most weeks of the year, but this is for the smallest numbers of users and an office could be in any building.

Buildings are permanent structures, in a fixed location and offering a defined amount of space with limited adaptability. However, for most of the time synagogue buildings are empty and unused. Ask yourself, how many hours (in an average pre-pandemic week) did you spend in your synagogue’s building? Synagogue buildings also confine the community to a specific location and impose limits on communal activities.

As we start to rethink what is normal in a post Covid world, should we not ask what we need from a synagogue – and can we free ourselves from the need to have a synagogue building?

 

 

2 Comments

  1. Miriam Greenwood

    It seems to me that the issue shouldn’t start with the building question but with how important it is to have personal contact. If we value in-person sharing of activities and look forward to a time when more of this can happen as Covid runs its course then we need somewhere for this sharing to take place. So that’s why we need a building.

  2. Jacqueline and John Morrison

    We definitely need a synagogue building – a Home

    While zoom has a place for members unable to attend services/activities, it can never replace the atmosphere, feeling, sense of belonging that the synagogue provides
    Without a synagogue building the community will not survive

    We are a social people, and need a communal Home to develop and thrive