It Takes All Sorts …
September 24, 2026

On Friday evening and Saturday morning, we celebrate both Shabbat and the First Day of Sukkot. One of the signature activities of Sukkot is the shaking of the lulav and etrog, which is based on a single verse in Torah:

On the first day you shall take the product of hadar trees, branches of palm trees, boughs of leafy trees, and willows of the brook, and you shall rejoice before the ETERNAL your God seven days.

Leviticus 23:40 tells us these are the four species, but doesn’t tell us why these particular ones are chosen. Cue wonderful speculation and storytelling to give reasons why! Let me share just one such explanation

A midrash says that the four species of growing things stand for the Jewish people. Just as the willow has neither taste nor fragrance, so some Jews have no knowledge of Torah and do not do good deeds. Just as the fruit of the palm (dates) has taste but no fragrance, so some Jews have knowledge of the Torah, but do not do good deeds. Just as the myrtle has fragrance but no taste, so some Jews have no knowledge of Torah, but do good deeds. And just as the Etrog has taste and fragrance, so some Jews have knowledge of the Torah and do good deeds.

One implicit message from this midrash is that all sorts of Jews exist and all have their place in the community. None of them are labelled as ‘not Jewish enough’. The willow is held just as much as the etrog when the mitzvah of waving or shaking the lulav is carried out. All are equally important.

We, at ELELS, take this principle to heart and apply it all year round. Please come and join us on Friday evening and / or on Saturday morning as we celebrate Sukkot.

Rabbi Richard Jacobi


PS Some of you will already have seen that King Solomon High School is holding a consultation about its future, with the option of closing on the table. This has been on the cards, and with only 55 students starting year 7 out of a possible 180 places, the problems at KSHS are there for all to see. You can read the Jewish Chronicle article here or visit https://kshsonline.uk/consultation/


PPS A reminder of the themes of my Yom Kippur morning sermon, in that a synagogue was attacked on Kol Nidre night … in Jerusalem by Jewish extremists. This statement by the Movement for Progressive Judaism on 23rd September:

We stand with Kehilat Kol HaNeshama, part of our sibling movement in Israel, after its synagogue was attacked again over Yom Kippur.

This was the fourth time in a month that the community had been targeted by Jewish extremists. Nobody should arrive for prayers on the holiest day of the Jewish year to discover that their synagogue has been broken into.

As Progressive Jews, we recognise the language that surrounds attacks like this. We hear repeatedly that our Judaism is not authentic and that we do not properly belong. We know, across the world, what that delegitimisation does. Eventually it stops being only words.

We welcome Yair Golan’s unequivocal condemnation. The Israeli Government and its representatives must be equally clear. These attacks need to be properly investigated, the people responsible held to account and Kol HaNeshama protected.

Progressive Jews should not have to fight for the right to pray safely in the Jewish state.

We send our love and solidarity to Rabbi Oded Mazor and the whole Kol HaNeshama community.

0 Comments