Our Torah portion for this week could not be more appropriately timed as the stories this week concerning the killers of PC Andrew Harper and the by-election at Clacton are among those leading the news agenda. Both connect with the opening verses of our Torah portion and its exhortation, “Tzedek, tzedek tirdof – Justice, justice shall you pursue!”
For many people across society, acts of violence warrant a higher penalty when they are against those who serve society by putting on uniforms and placing themselves in dangerous situations. Although PC Andrew Harper, like any police officer, knew that the potential for a fatal incident existed, he and all officers have the right to expect that our society acts to discourage people from attacking the uniformed services. When we pray for the King and country, we pray for all who help our country to be a civilised, fair, and just nation.
The government does seem to be listening and responding to this principle. The size of our prison population is something for us to discuss another day, but the important principles are about having a justice system that works efficiently and effectively.
Indeed, that is the essence of the repetition of the word for justice – it has been interpreted that justice must be done, and be seen to be done; or that a just decision must be reached, through methods that are also just. Bachya ben Asher commented, “Justice, whether to your profit or loss, whether in word or in action, whether to Jew or non-Jew.” In this context, we should note that the verse before highlights “You shall not judge unfairly: you shall show no partiality; you shall not take bribes, for bribes blind the eyes of the discerning and upset the plea of the just.” (Deut. 16:19)
In this verse, we also see the flip-side of our support for the ‘servants of the crown’. Anyone who takes a position of power in the state’s infrastructure or in organisations that seek to build and sustain civil society, our synagogue and me as your rabbi included, must also accept that they are held to a high standard of behaviour. Those with the most power have to be held to the highest standards!
In the Bible, both Moses and King David found out about this principle. Moses was barred by God from entering the promised land for the sin of hitting a rock, when God told him to speak to it so that it would bring forth water. King David was forbidden by God from building the Temple because of how he went about waging war and, in particular, how he ensured Uriah was killed in battle so that he could marry Bathsheba.
Police officers who use their power to do harm have to be held to account with higher penalties than a civilian committing the same crime. Similarly, as Deuteronomy stated, people in public offices have to act beyond reproach. Contemporary rules of conduct for public life (e.g. the Nolan Principles) seek to ensure that nothing influences elected or appointed office holders towards acting improperly.
This latter point brings me to today’s by-election in Clacton. No person in roles that give them power and influence should seek to avoid scrutiny that ensures they are, and are seen to be, acting properly. Such systems of scrutiny are not “establishment” instruments, in fact they are the exact opposite. They are the means by which the general public can have confidence in the people and systems that sustain civil society.
Whatever the outcome of the by-election, I would hope we all support the roles of shof’tim v’shot’rim, the opening two words of our Torah portion. The magistrates who judge cases (Shof’tim) and the officials who ensure that judgements are enforced (Shot’rim) are important to our society. We need to know that those with power are not being swayed unduly and, to paraphrase our Torah portion, that “justice is being pursued justly.”
Rabbi Richard Jacobi
0 Comments