Anarchy or Rules-based Order?
February 12, 2026

One question I often ask year 4 children when they come to visit our synagogue is to think about what their school would be like if there were absolutely no rules at all. Initially, many are excited by the idea, but when they – even at age 8 or 9 – start to think it through, they come to realise that rules are necessary to keep everyone safe, to respect property, and to enable each of them to thrive.

This week’s Torah portion, parshat Mishpatim, which means ‘rules’ or ‘ordinances’, is one we will study together on Saturday morning. It is reckoned to contain 53 of the suggested 613 commandments, so it does live up to its title. It is a collection of what we would nowadays call civil and criminal laws, as well as rules relating to religious practice.

After last week’s Torah portion with the dramatic story of revelation and the setting out of the famous ten statements or commandments, this is the detail of how a society ensures that it can, like the school of those year 4 children, function in the interests of all.

Questions around justice, ethical behaviour, and the rule of law are raised in every generation. They are as pertinent to our civil society in 2026 as they were to the Israelites of the biblical period. We like to think there has been progress, but human nature being what it is, there will always be some people who succumb to temptations of different types.

Nationally, we have seen this in the continuing news stories connected to Jeffrey Epstein in some way. We also see it in every news bulletin we see or hear. All these are reminders that in order to remain a civilised society, we need to work on evolving rules and laws so that as criminals change their activities, society adapts to close loopholes, create new laws, and so on. Law has to be living and evolving if we are to avoid a descent into anarchy.

From the perspective of Progressive Judaism, this evolution is linked to our general principle that as humanity learns more about everything in and beyond our world, so laws and rules, ethics and rituals should evolve. This does NOT mean we follow trends, but we set ourselves the delicate and important task of discerning the difference between fads and fashions on the one hand, and important learning and revelation on the other.

Such learning can only come when we value knowledge, understanding and expertise, which themselves must be coupled with challenge and accountability. In the social media age, the opinionated voice of an “influencer” must not have greater sway than the wisdom of peer-reviewed scholarship.

May we hold to the values of our Judaism and resist the temptation to follow those who seek to influence others for their own gain. May the principles of parshat Mishpatim help us to seek wise and sound rules and laws that help sustain a stable society for this generation of year 4 school children and the next.

Shabbat shalom,

Rabbi Richard Jacobi

0 Comments