When you read this, we shall be nearing the very last days of Chanukah. I hope that you have enjoyed lighting your Chanukiah after dusk every evening and that you have enjoyed stuffing yourselves with crispy latkes and jammy doughnuts! The blessings for lighting the candles and Maoz Tzur can be found on p. 399 of your siddur.
Chanukah celebrates a great victory, after a bitter war that lasted three years. The Jews of Israel had defeated the Greek army and were able to return to their capital, Jerusalem, and so at long last were able to clean and rededicate their holy Temple. Regular daily services resumed in the Temple, and the people were once more ruled by their own priests (Cohanim) and by a new dynasty of Jewish kings and queens, the Hasmoneans. The rededication took place on 25th Kislev 164 BCE, the date of Chanukah.
So on Chanukah we celebrate the end of a three-year war. It was a final end, an absolute victory. The Jews were victorious; the Greek armies were utterly defeated.
Nowadays, victories don’t seem to be quite as clear cut. A terrible war against Hamas in Gaza has raged for over two years. And although a ceasefire was supposed to end the fighting, Hamas is clearly still very much in charge in Gaza. It has failed to disarm or let another civilian authority take over the government. The city has been reduced to rubble, tens of thousands have lost their lives. And if this war has at last spluttered to an end, Israel is still left threatened and vulnerable. Much as they were in October 2023. What has been achieved?
Much the same has happened after nearly four years of fighting between Russia and the Ukraine. Even if the Americans do manage to impose their ‘peace deal’, tens of thousands have lost their lives. And Ukraine will be expected to surrender a lot of their territory. Fighting may at last stop, but there has been no real victory, no resolution of the fundamental issues behind the conflict.
Two bitter conflicts in different parts of our world. If the poet T S Eliot were still alive today, he might have written:
‘This is the way the wars end – Not with a bang but a whimper.’
It’s all rather depressing. Chanukah is supposed to be a happy festival, when we forget the many troubles of the world. So remember that the festival is celebrated for eight days, not just for a single day. The number of candles grows; slowly and steadily the light increases. So the lesson is that we have to be patient. And to hold on to our faith that, with God’s help, peace, understanding and harmony between peoples and religions will grow. Not in a single day, with a ‘ceasefire’ or a ‘peace deal’, but perhaps in our lifetimes.
May all the little lights of Chanukah continue to grow in number and brightness! Happy Chanukah!
Rabbi David Hulbert
0 Comments