You and your Genes
February 20, 2025

I did not know, until very recently, that a fault in the BRCA gene can double the risk of prostate cancer in men to a 1 in 4 chance. Better known, to me at least, is that faults in the BRCA gene can increase the risk of breast cancer in women to around 70%, compared to a general population risk of 12%. Among Ashkenazi Jews, around 1 in 40 will have the faults in the BRCA gene that lead to these increased cancer risks. The risk is raised less if you are of Sephardi background, but is still higher than the national average.

 

The good news is that FREE testing is available through the NHS Jewish BRCA Testing Programme. I have just signed up to be tested and let me explain why.

 

There is a fundamental Jewish imperative to do all that we can to save lives, including our own. If I should find out that I don’t have the faulty BRCA gene, that helps me, and will also help my children and grandchildren.

 

If, on the other hand, I find out that I do have the faulty gene, then there might be a greater incentive for them to test. I know of at least one courageous woman who decided a double mastectomy was preferable to the elevated risk of cancer. Knowledge, as they say, is power. She was able to make this choice and I’d rather more people had the power, than find at some point they have developed a cancer they might have prevented.

 

A positive result doesn’t necessitate the sort of radical action that she took, as your life situation and personal preferences might suggest a different response. You or I might be monitored more closely, and if a cancer did develop, we might find out earlier and be treated sooner, with better chances. And, remember, a negative test result is good news that gives you a different sort of knowledge and power!

 

The choices about whether to be tested and what to do following a positive result are all supported by access to counsellors and support. There is a lot of experience and knowledge available to help any and all of us.

 

So, please consider this for yourself and discuss this with other members of your family. You can begin by visiting the website https://jewishbrca.org . You can also get helpful information from https://www.jnetics.org . (Please note, BRCA testing is different from the wider genetic testing that jnetics offer, such as at the event on Wednesday 26th February.)

 

For 125 years, Liberal Judaism has been advocating for individuals to make informed choices. In this sort of health matter, please apply the same logic, and look after your own health and that of your family. I’m also here for your feedback, questions, and comment.

 

Rabbi Richard Jacobi

 

 

0 Comments