Over the past few days, a verse from the Book of Jeremiah has been used to accompany images of six people: “A cry is heard in Ramah – wailing, bitter weeping – Rachel weeping for her children. She refuses to be comforted for her children, who are gone.” (Jer. 31:15)
In part, this verse has been used because Rachel Goldberg-Polin is the mother of Hersh, the hostage who the Board of Deputies asked us to adopt, and who was murdered late last week. He was killed, alongside Carmel Gat, Eden Yerushalmi, Alexander Lobanov, Almog Sarusi, and Ori Danino, as Israeli forces closed in on the tunnels in which they were being held captive.
The biblical text is set in the wake of the Babylonian conquest of Judea and the destruction of the First Temple in Jerusalem. It was a catastrophe that is still memorialised by Judaism every Tisha B’Av. Here, in the weeks of consolation that bridge between Tisha B’Av and Rosh Hashanah, we have a fresh tragedy to grieve.
Last Sunday night, I opened a Zoom room and around 40 people joined me in grief and sorrow, mingled for some with anger that they could have been released had a cease-fire deal been done. In spite of the fact that none of us had ever met Hersh or his parents – Jon Polin and Rachel Goldberg-Polin and younger sisters – Leebie and Orly – we felt this loss very strongly. Tears were shed by some and there was a little comfort drawn from the knowledge that others shared our sense of upset.
Our grief at this awful news is just the merest glimpse of what Hersh’s family have been feeling. Yet, again, on Tuesday at this funeral, Rachel Goldberg-Polin delivered incredible sentiments of loss, gratitude, apology, and hope. The full text of Rachel Goldberg-Polin’s eulogy for her son can be found here.
For us as individuals and as a community, we will have to adapt to these tragic deaths. Now we know that Hersh will definitely not ever come and sit in our sanctuary, we will no longer save a seat for him. The prayer for Israel that we say every Shabbat morning will change again. This Shabbat and for the following three weeks, we will mention before Kaddish Hersh and the other five people who were murdered alongside him. As soon as we can, and as kindly suggested by an anonymous donor, we will place a leaf on the Tree of Life for Hersh Goldberg-Polin.
I shall write a letter of condolence on behalf of our synagogue community. If you wish to write to the family, please send your letters, cards or emails to Sam in the office. We will forward them on Monday 16th September, via the Board of Deputies, to the family.
Some of you might wish to express your feelings that more needs to be done by the current government of Israel to bring the remaining hostages home alive. For myself, I note the priority in Jewish laws given to redeeming captives – it’s mentioned in the Amidah in every service, evening, morning, and afternoon! From my rabbinic perspective, a deal could have been done, except that the current government wishes to remain in power and can only do so while there is no deal. On Sunday afternoon, I joined with those Jews – Israeli and diaspora – who cried “Bushah!” Shame on those who made a ceasefire deal impossible.
I acknowledge too that others will view the current situation differently to me, and we need to embrace the range of legitimate responses to this painful situation and continue to be one community with more that we share in common.
We all, however, have very little power in this situation. So, we must focus on using words and deeds that promote harmony and peaceful co-existence here in our part of the UK. We can also encourage those who live out our values in Israel – who support those communities devastated by the attacks on 7th October and since then, who help displaced individuals and families, who oppose violent settler expansion in the West Bank.
The biblical exile that saw Rachel, as a metaphor for all Jews, weeping for her children, came to an end and Jewish life renewed itself. We must continue to believe that this time of war will pass and that a more peaceful and positive time will come, even though we can’t currently see a path towards that time.
We, as a community, will continue to comfort mourners, to visit the sick, and also to help bride and groom to rejoice – as we do for Max and Jenni on Shabbat morning. We will also continue to teach our children diligently and joyfully, as the Cheder year re-starts with the annual fete this coming Sunday afternoon. If we can model the world as we wish it to be – filled with kind, loving words and deeds – then, maybe, others will join us!
Rabbi Richard Jacobi
The full link to Rachel Goldberg-Polin’s eulogy is: https://www.timesofisrael.com/my-sweet-boy-hersh-we-tried-so-desperately-to-save-you/
0 Comments